1. Louis
2. Cloverleaf / Buddy's
3. Green Lantern
4. Shields [[though I've only had their pizza a couple of times - it's OK, just not as good as the above)

Louis default pizza is a bit underdone, so you ask for it well done and it comes out perfect. Ditto Cloverleaf. Buddy's *usually* comes out right, but sometimes is also underdone. I think when they are busy they try to rush things a bit.

As for the "regular" pizza places:

1. Primo's
2. Toramina's
3. Jet's / Hungry Howie's
4. Papa Romano's
5. Everyone else