After a few bad experiences on the island with thugs strolling in the middle of the street blocking traffic like they owned the road, blasting music, foul language [[in front of the grandkids), we decided not to go anymore at certain times of the day, during certain seasons, on holidays, in the warm weather, etc.
The last time we were there we went very early in the morning and was able to enjoy the park and get out of the car. The time before that was in the dead of winter when no one was there.
I feel much safer at Metro. There are certain groups at Metro that try to take over the park but with the sheriff's office patrolling and keeping the peace, I feel I and my family are better off.
I still have my memories of Belle Isle from childhood and that will have to be enough until someone gets a handle on the unruly crowds.