I myself live in Wayne, I pay around $600 for a house that was valued at $136k almost 3yrs ago.I have my policy through Grange , As well as the 2 vehicles I have insured. Until earlier this year I had one vehicle with Grange and the other with AAA. My AAA bill was almost as much as my house as for my 16yr old auto. I do though keep my road service with AAA. But I have heard complaints about pretty much all the insurance companies mentioned here. Good luck with your search.