One other thing I noticed while reading about this building that I don't recall seeing in this thread is that it's on a historical register. Not sure how that affects use.
I don't really care if it's a cafe', apartment, law office or whatever. I do have a problem with fussy neighbors throwing their weight around.
I think if I was Mayor, I'd be half tempted to override the planning commission and approve the restaurant. Or an Adult Bookstore.
Bookmarks