Hudson's 30 Years Ago Today

[dtowncitylover]

Better late than never, but today marked 30 years of Hudson's Downtown closure. Below is a link of an awesome report by Channel 7's Erik Smith. I never knew the grandeur of the store, only her hollow hulk. Enjoy, though...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5YLF...&feature=share

[dtowncitylover]

Sorry guys, I just realized it's 2014!!!!! [[Hudson's closed in '83). I guess we could mark 31 years. But the video is still cool, and I don't remember it being posted on here [[of course I could be wrong about that too!)

[DetroitPlanner]

LOL I was about to say in 1984 I was driving. I am positive I went there the last time with my family when I was not yet driving.

It was a huge store. One of my fondest memories was going to it after going to the dentist as a younging. Mom would take me to the David Whitney building on the bus then over to the Hudson Mezzanine for Vernor's and a hot dog.

To those who never made it there, it is difficult to explain how huge the store was. If you have made it to Marshall Field or Macy's, well Hudson's seemed bigger! Though technically I believe that Macy's on Herald Square was still bigger. All of these big stores are just shells of their former selves. I can recall there being a mind-boggling amount of stuff you could get at Hudson's when I was young. Appliances, sewing stuff, rare stamps, bookstores, records [[yeah I am old), and of course the rainbow or bargain basement. Today's department stores are considered to be full line when they sell home goods, clothes, and some furniture. Things have changed a lot over the 40 years.

[Ray1936]

Hudson's meant their Christmas Lionel train display. I was taken there every year after "the" war [[you know what I mean) to drool over the offerings. Here's a young Ray1936 c. 1948 posing with his layout.

[mikefmich]

Hudson's meant their Christmas Lionel train display. I was taken there every year after "the" war [[you know what I mean) to drool over the offerings. Here's a young Ray1936 c. 1948 posing with his layout.

Ray, I gotta hand it to you, I'm drooling here. I still have hold of my Lionel stuff, but I can tell just from one end of your setup, you were way past what I had. My cousin who was about 6 yrs. younger than you had a MASSIVE set up. When my Uncle Ray got back from the South Pacific he spoiled his oldest boy rotten with a Lionel set-up that was the thing of dreams too.

[Honky Tonk]

Hudson's meant their Christmas Lionel train display. I was taken there every year after "the" war [[you know what I mean) to drool over the offerings. Here's a young Ray1936 c. 1948 posing with his layout.

WHAT!?! No "ZW" transformer??? Go big or go home, Ray!

[Ray1936]

WHAT!?! No "ZW" transformer??? Go big or go home, Ray!

Yeah, the ZW came out in 1949, and I was already three years into the layout. Had to settle for the ugly ones. [[ZW had rheostats that were like a throttle on a real train.....great for playing engineer!)

[beachboy]

Yeah, the ZW came out in 1949, and I was already three years into the layout. Had to settle for the ugly ones. [[ZW had rheostats that were like a throttle on a real train.....great for playing engineer!)

Ray,you've got a great memory!! My best friend
had two ZW's controlling three trains on his [[Dad's)
basement layout. Remember the smoke pellets to
put in the locomotive? Choo-choo!!

Not to be outdone, my Dad built an HO scale layout
on a 4x8 plywood, framed it w/ legs and we [[I say
that loosely) added to it over two decades. All the
track, rolling stock etc. from JL Hudson's.

memories... <sobble>

[Honky Tonk]

Ray,you've got a great memory!! My best friend
had two ZW's controlling three trains on his [[Dad's)
basement layout. Remember the smoke pellets to
put in the locomotive? Choo-choo!!

Not to be outdone, my Dad built an HO scale layout
on a 4x8 plywood, framed it w/ legs and we [[I say
that loosely) added to it over two decades. All the
track, rolling stock etc. from JL Hudson's.

memories... <sobble>

My locomotive didn't take the pellets, it took the drops instead. Do any of you guys now if "Cartrain" is still in existence?

[EastsideAl]

Goodness, I have so many memories of that store. My grandmother worked there for over 20 years, behind a cosmetics counter, so I was in there a lot as a kid. Later, when I was changing buses downtown every day on my way to/from school, Hudson's became a major hangout and refuge for me. I loved it there.

By the time I left for college though. the store was clearly in decline. Floors and parts of floors were closed, most of the upper floors were vacated, many departments seemed chronically understaffed, and many fewer elevators were in operation. By the time I was done in college and working downtown the store had closed.

[Dan Wesson]

Wasn't Crowleys the store with the mezzanine? It was where I first had what was called a Boston Cooler, basically a Vernor's with a scoop or two of vanilla ice cream. My Mom and Aunt both worked there and we would usually end up sitting at the counter.

I would hop on the Van Dyke bus at the corner of Phelps get a transfer ticket and then take the Gratiot bus downtown. Ding Ding, catch the drivers eye and get off.

[DetroitPlanner]

Wasn't Crowleys the store with the mezzanine? It was where I first had what was called a Boston Cooler, basically a Vernor's with a scoop or two of vanilla ice cream. My Mom and Aunt both worked there and we would usually end up sitting at the counter.

It could have been. I was real young then.

[chicagoforlife]

I'm not sure of the history of the Hudson's store in Detroit but the Marshall Field's store on State Street in Chicago was built in 1892. The Architect was Daniel Burnham he also designed the Dime Building, Ford Building and Majestic Building's in Detroit. The Majestic Building was located where 1001 Woodward is currently located.

I'm not sure how much bigger Hudson's was but I know the current Marshall Field's in Chicago is the second largest store in the world.

[DetroitPlanner]

I'm not sure how much bigger Hudson's was but I know the current Marshall Field's in Chicago is the second largest store in the world.

Hudson's never had the grandeur of the MF. It did not have enormous multi-story light wells. It was more like a huge version of Carson's. About 20 years ago MF went through a big transformation and additional space was removed when a large central escalator lobby was installed. This took out tens of thousands of square feet of space, but at least allowed the rest of the store to look more full. Prior to then, it still had several closed floors.

[Sharnelle]

When I was about 4 yrs old I believed that the "J. L." referred to a jail. In my mind J L Hudson's was a combo amazing store and jail on the same downtown property. My parents thought this misconception was hilarious and didn't set me straight. Other than that, I remember a play area on an upper floor with miniature rooms of a pretend house. Later I remember being at Northland on opening day which happened to be my birthday.

[A2Mike]

Hudson's never had the grandeur of the MF. It did not have enormous multi-story light wells. It was more like a huge version of Carson's. About 20 years ago MF went through a big transformation and additional space was removed when a large central escalator lobby was installed. This took out tens of thousands of square feet of space, but at least allowed the rest of the store to look more full. Prior to then, it still had several closed floors.

The Marshall Field building is a little smaller than Hudson's but Burnham's unified design and stone construction make it a more stately presence than the Hudson's building, which grew incrementally and was faced with a frankly unattractive reddish-brown brick. I am speaking strictly of the architectural character of the respective stores. As retail and civic institutions both stores had very high quality merchandise and highly accommodating customer policies, and both deserved the high regard they enjoyed. I knew Hudson's well growing up in Detroit in the 50's and 60's, and when I moved to Chicago in the 70's I was pleased to find that Field's atmosphere still resembled that of Hudson's some years earlier, while Hudson's sadly showed increasing signs of decline. Nonetheless, I'm pleased to have known both fine stores in their heydays. One cherished memory of Hudson's will always be that big red sign in the night sky, even from way out Gratiot or Grand River a reassuring sight. Field's, too, left me with very good memories. Their great furniture department was where I fitted out my first adult home, and I would still walk from Fullerton to the Loop for a pecan caramel banana split at Field's Crystal Palace!

[MikeyinBrooklyn]

I'm not sure how much bigger Hudson's was but I know the current Marshall Field's in Chicago is the second largest store in the world.

I think there has been some dispute about which stores were the biggest. If I recall what I've read in the past, Hudson's had more sq ft total than Macy's, but Macy's had more sq ft dedicated to sales floor [[Hudson's having more dedicated to office space). I am not sure how Marshall Field's measured in total or sales floor. I will say that visiting that store [[now Macy's) I don't get a sense of the grandeur that Hudson's had, but I realize that it has been done over [[and heck, if Hudson's were still with us today, the downtown flagship would be a bland Macy's in a red brick shell, too). I think Macy's has done itself long-term harm by taking the magic out of department stores. Now, you might as well shop online.

Btw Sharnelle, your story is hilarious. JaiL Hudson's. Sounds like the name of a dive bar.

[chicagoforlife]

I think there has been some dispute about which stores were the biggest. If I recall what I've read in the past, Hudson's had more sq ft total than Macy's, but Macy's had more sq ft dedicated to sales floor [[Hudson's having more dedicated to office space). I am not sure how Marshall Field's measured in total or sales floor. I will say that visiting that store [[now Macy's) I don't get a sense of the grandeur that Hudson's had, but I realize that it has been done over [[and heck, if Hudson's were still with us today, the downtown flagship would be a bland Macy's in a red brick shell, too). I think Macy's has done itself long-term harm by taking the magic out of department stores. Now, you might as well shop online.

Btw Sharnelle, your story is hilarious. JaiL Hudson's. Sounds like the name of a dive bar.

Truthfully I haven't been in that store since they changed the name.

[Bham1982]

I think Macy's has done itself long-term harm by taking the magic out of department stores. Now, you might as well shop online.

Have you been to the Macys Herald Square flagship lately [[say last few months)? The renovations are pretty impressive.

They're pouring $500 million into a renovation/expansion, and it shows. Fancy new restaurants, more upscale offerings, giant new windows, and marble everywhere.

[beachboy]

Wasn't Crowleys the store with the mezzanine? It was where I first had what was called a Boston Cooler, basically a Vernor's with a scoop or two of vanilla ice cream.

Wow, memories... this kid from the sticks was soooo impressed with Hudson's -- Crowleys had a more "light" sort of feeling but seemed way smaller. Hudson's was a warren of hallways, arcane stairways, and those wonderful escalators!! Mom and Dad would park me in the music store while Mom went shopping and Dad took a nap in the lounge. Then we would have lunch in the Riverview Room. I still have several books from Hudson's mezzanine that I purchased in the early 1970s. What a wonderful time to be alive!!

[EastsideAl]

Wasn't Crowleys the store with the mezzanine?

Crowley's had a mezzanine that was open and actually overlooked the first floor. With a lunch counter/soda fountain, as you remember.

I had a great-aunt who worked at Crowley's, also in the cosmetics department. My grandmother would lord the superiority of her workplace at Hudson's over her sister-in-law's place at Crowley's every chance she would get. Made for some awkward family parties sometimes.

One thing that I think everyone recalls about Crowley's is the clacking of the wooden escalators that echoed throughout the cavernous ground floor and the rest of the store. My grandmother always openly wondered how my great-aunt could "tolerate all that racket".

[MikeyinBrooklyn]

I wish I remembered it better. I do remember thinking it was like going into a palace, totally unlike the suburban stores. And I remember going with my Mom on her lunch break to the office/department in the store where they had an interior decorator when we had our dining room redone. I can't imagine a department store having that kind of service these days! And I don't think Macy's in NY or the old Marshall Field's in Chicago can hold a candle to it.

[Gilmour]

I remember my mother, grandmother and I occasionally shopping at
Hudson's. My favorite memory of Hudson's is going to see the window
display at Christmas with my family. Talking about being old, I was
born in Detroit during WW11 in Providence Hospital.

[Wingnatic]

Erik is doing well and just commented on Facebook that him and his wife are currently celebrating their 48th wedding anniversary , last I heard Capt. Dennis is flying for a hospital transport in Toledo

[Kimmiann]

Thanks, Wingnatic - I was thinking that very [[Erik Smith & Captain Dennis) question!