Council member considers closing gas stations, restaurants overnight

**Zacha341** · January-25-12, 07:06 AM

Detroit City Council member considers closing gas stations, restaurants overnight

Restricted hours would be between 11 p.m., 5 a.m.

http://www.clickondetroit.com/news/D...z/-/index.html

**Dexlin** · January-25-12, 07:21 AM

Brown, former deputy police chief for the city, said after hours are also prime hours for crime to happen. He referenced the recent fatal shooting of a Highland Park gas station clerk at 3:30 a.m.

Isn't this just the most defeatist thing you've heard in awhile? I understand wanting to protect people, but doesn't this mean the criminals have won? And, then you end up hurting businesses because of the crime that happens to a few on any given night. Seems like there is a better way from which to attack the problem, particularly now that more police are supposedly out from behind their desks and on the streets during the night.

**Zacha341** · January-25-12, 07:33 AM

Agreed. This only make Detroit more distinct in a bad way! And more of reason to leave and certainly not an incentive for existing business or new business initiatives. As citizens I guess it just means batten down and make sure you have your gas and water before it get too late at night --

-- ! That's already becoming the lifestyle for many adapting to the increasing crime.... so well ok.

Originally Posted by Dexlin

Isn't this just the most defeatist thing you've heard in awhile? I understand wanting to protect people, but doesn't this mean the criminals have won? And, then you end up hurting businesses because of the crime that happens to a few on any given night. Seems like there is a better way from which to attack the problem, particularly now that more police are supposedly out from behind their desks and on the streets during the night.

**iheartthed** · January-25-12, 08:01 AM

Originally Posted by Dexlin

Isn't this just the most defeatist thing you've heard in awhile? I understand wanting to protect people, but doesn't this mean the criminals have won? And, then you end up hurting businesses because of the crime that happens to a few on any given night. Seems like there is a better way from which to attack the problem, particularly now that more police are supposedly out from behind their desks and on the streets during the night.

Well, it's not exactly unheard of for governments to regulate enterprise in the name of public safety.

**bailey** · January-25-12, 09:33 AM

Originally Posted by iheartthed

Well, it's not exactly unheard of for governments to regulate enterprise in the name of public safety.

True, but real cities don't close at 11pm.

**rjlj** · January-25-12, 09:37 AM

So by closing at night you succumb to the bad people, essentaillly telling them that our city has been overpowered by you and we can't police you and that you win.

Great idea.

Buy American · January-25-12, 08:41 AM

Originally Posted by Dexlin

Isn't this just the most defeatist thing you've heard in awhile? I understand wanting to protect people, but doesn't this mean the criminals have won? And, then you end up hurting businesses because of the crime that happens to a few on any given night. Seems like there is a better way from which to attack the problem, particularly now that more police are supposedly out from behind their desks and on the streets during the night.

There are more cops on the street and there will be even more in the near future, however, they can't be on every corner where there is a convenience store or gas station in the entire City of Detroit. As I said before, something more drastic needs to be done to deter crime within Detroit, like S.T.R.E.S.S., or more gang squads throughout the City. Specialized cops who are trained to fight these thugs and get them off the streets and in prison. Bing sending EMS, firefighters and cops to seminars to learn how to talk nicely to citizens in Detroit is the biggest joke and waste of taxpayer money I've ever seen.

**iheartthed** · January-25-12, 08:46 AM

Originally Posted by Buy American

There are more cops on the street and there will be even more in the near future, however, they can't be on every corner where there is a convenience store or gas station in the entire City of Detroit. As I said before, something more drastic needs to be done to deter crime within Detroit, like S.T.R.E.S.S., or more gang squads throughout the City. Specialized cops who are trained to fight these thugs and get them off the streets and in prison. Bing sending EMS, firefighters and cops to seminars to learn how to talk nicely to citizens in Detroit is the biggest joke and waste of taxpayer money I've ever seen.

If STRESS was effective then it wouldn't have been cut.

**Detroit Stylin** · January-25-12, 09:26 AM

Originally Posted by iheartthed

If STRESS was effective then it wouldn't have been cut.

You have to understand....all Buy American wants is a gestapo like police force that will be all too willing bash in innocent black men's heads and maybe even chip in a body or two so HE feels safe...

**Danny** · January-25-12, 09:30 AM

Let's bring back STRESS!

Buy American · January-25-12, 09:46 AM

Originally Posted by Detroit Stylin

You have to understand....all Buy American wants is a gestapo like police force that will be all too willing bash in innocent black men's heads and maybe even chip in a body or two so HE feels safe...

You've got it backwards stylin...it's the thugs that are bashing in innocent black men's heads and murdering people, not the police. Obviously, all you care about is race and the rights of the criminals in your city, not safety, which in my opinion, would be top priority.
As far as ME feeling safe....I do...because I live in a community where people care about each other, we look out for each other, our police force is effective and they don't take the crap that the thugs hand out. Believe me, no one's rights are violated either...the thugs are all protected against nazi type tactics.

**Wild** · January-25-12, 03:22 PM

Originally Posted by Detroit Stylin

You have to understand....all Buy American wants is a gestapo like police force that will be all too willing bash in innocent black men's heads and maybe even chip in a body or two so HE feels safe...

I'm sorry, I don't agree with you. I'm Black and I live in this city and I feel the same way. Things have gotten too out of hand. At this point, I think that a STRESS type unit or the National Guard needs to be brought in.

**Detroit Stylin** · January-25-12, 09:34 AM

But on some for real....this is some real stupid shit and we need to do a better job at electing our council members...preferably some who have actually been to other large, major cities...

what council man was it?

**coracle** · January-25-12, 10:02 AM

Without commenting on whether it's a good idea or not I think it will have two effects. First some criminals will "eat" earlier; particularly just before11 pm, and secondly there will be an increase in planned home invasions after 11 pm. Criminals are not going to reduce their activities because of a few road blocks put in their way. They might start looking for what's still open after 11 outside Detroit. It might turn out to be a case of spread the pain.

**Bham1982** · January-25-12, 10:22 AM

This would have no effect on crime and just drive more decent folks to the suburbs.

Criminals aren't going to stop just because you changed the hours of operation. They hit the places overnight because that's the best opportunity. If the establishments close at 11, they'll just hit them after dark until closing.

**iheartthed** · January-25-12, 10:41 AM

Originally Posted by Bham1982

Criminals aren't going to stop just because you changed the hours of operation. They hit the places overnight because that's the best opportunity. If the establishments close at 11, they'll just hit them after dark until closing.

Crime is about opportunity and criminals won't hold up crowded gas stations. The criminals are more likely to change their targets than they are to rob crowded stations.

**Bham1982** · January-25-12, 11:31 AM

Originally Posted by iheartthed

Crime is about opportunity and criminals won't hold up crowded gas stations. The criminals are more likely to change their targets than they are to rob crowded stations.

Gas stations aren't uniformly busy throughout the day, nor are they uniformly empty throughout the night.

I think that criminals would continue to be criminals, and would strike at the most opportune times available to them.

**internet_pseudopod** · January-25-12, 10:29 AM

Oddly enough I don't think this is too bad of an idea. I prefer the idea where an establishment that wants to be a 24 hour establishment would have to hire armed security to be there during those late night hours. It may force some of these businesses that have random panhandlers hanging around and young dudes selling weed/pills/crack on the premises to take some responsibility for their property.

I'm not that old and I can remember when the majority of liquor stores and coney islands used to close at night. The 24 hour brightly lit gas station is an invention of the mid to late 90's. There wouldn't be much injury if things went back to the way they were.

**Wheels** · January-25-12, 10:32 AM

To me this is close to last person out turn out the lights?

**313WX** · January-25-12, 10:36 AM

As liberal as I am, it's unonstitutional.

A privately-owned establishment should have the right to regulate their own hours of operation. No ifs, ands or buts about it. That's not to say they have the right to restrict who can patronize their business, since they're a BUSINESS that accepts public money for profit.

What the city CAN do is beef up the enforcement of laws to make these establishments safer at night. It should also be the fault of the business if they permit loitering and a crime occurs as a result of the loitering.

Besides, it will also lead to a loss of jobs. There are a lot of people who work in these gas stations and restaurants at night who will no longer be needed since the government regulated them out of a job.

**iheartthed** · January-25-12, 10:43 AM

Originally Posted by 313WX

As liberal as I am, it's unonstitutional.

A privately-owned establishment should have the right to regulate their own hours of operation. No ifs, ands or buts about it. That's not to say they have the right to restrict who can patronize their business, since they're a BUSINESS that accepts public money for profit.

They don't have that right hence why bars must close at 2am in Michigan.

**1953** · January-25-12, 10:50 AM

This is getting absurd.

First, they ban parking on the street, so bad guys don't steal cars.

Now, they want to ban eating and fueling late, so bad guys don't commit crimes at restaurants and gas stations.

Next, they want to ban living in Detroit, to prevent home invasions.

Totally insane.

**Wesley Mouch** · January-25-12, 11:19 AM

Originally Posted by 1953

This is getting absurd.

First, they ban parking on the street, so bad guys don't steal cars.

Now, they want to ban eating and fueling late, so bad guys don't commit crimes at restaurants and gas stations.

Next, they want to ban living in Detroit, to prevent home invasions.

Totally insane.

Might work. Since living in Detroit is proven to be a health hazard, like smoking -- it make sense and perhaps we have an obligation to ban living in Detroit. I think the Democratic party can get behind this.